Settings

Language, shortcuts & timezone

Language

Timezone

Time zone changes apply on this device. A new device may start at GMT+8; check match times before reading.

콘텐츠로 건너뛰기
추천

설정

선호 설정 사용자 정의

오프사이드 리뷰: 위치만으로는 결정을 설명할 수 없습니다

Opta Tips Team 작성 업데이트됨

관련 연락처, 공격수 포지션 및 개입 상황을 검토하고, 공식 결정과 여전히 정지된 이미지 및 경기 데이터의 한계를 구분하세요.

Offside review diagram: identify relevant contact, check position relative to ball and second-last opponent, then involvement under Law 11; OptaTips logo at lower right.

Being in an offside position is not, by itself, an offence. A match review needs to establish the relevant moment of a team-mate’s play or touch and whether the positioned attacker then became involved in a way covered by Law 11.

A freeze-frame of a runner standing beyond a defender does not answer every part of that question. You need the ball’s position, the second-last opponent, the timing of the relevant contact and what the attacker actually did.

The practical aim is to review the sequence carefully without turning one still image into a confident explanation that the available footage cannot support.

Use the law applicable to the competition

IFAB’s current Law 11 is the primary reference for the distinctions discussed here. Check the edition and competition arrangements applicable to the fixture you are reviewing. A publicly discussed proposal or a trial is not automatically the rule for every match.

The familiar position test concerns an attacker’s relevant body parts in the opponents’ half and their relationship to both the ball and the second-last opponent. Hands and arms are excluded from that position assessment.

Do not casually substitute “last defender” for the second-last opponent. Opponents include the goalkeeper, but the goalkeeper need not be the opponent nearest the goal line in the particular sequence.

Those basic conditions do not decide every incident. An explainer should distinguish the position question from the subsequent offence question and leave official close-line measurement to the available evidence and authorised process.

Find the relevant contact before drawing a line

Offside position is assessed in relation to the relevant play or touch by a team-mate, not simply when the attacker receives the ball. A runner can cross a defensive line while the pass travels and still have started from a lawful position.

Conversely, an attacker can move back towards the ball after being beyond the relevant line at the moment that matters. Their later location does not, on its own, erase the earlier position assessment.

Use the contact convention stated in the applicable law, including any specific treatment of a goalkeeper’s throw. Avoid assuming that the frame in which a ball visibly separates from a boot is always the precisely established reference frame.

If the broadcast skips the contact or the angle obscures it, say so. Choosing a convenient nearby frame can change the apparent answer. A reconstruction should not conceal that uncertainty behind a sharp-looking drawn line.

Separate involvement from simple proximity

An attacker in an offside position may become involved by playing or touching a team-mate’s ball. Involvement can also concern interference with an opponent, including specified situations involving a challenge, line of vision or an action that affects an opponent’s ability to play the ball.

The useful review question is which action allegedly mattered. “He was standing there” is incomplete. Identify whether the claim concerns a touch, an opponent being challenged, a goalkeeper’s view being obstructed or another relevant action.

Consider two invented sequences. In the first, a positioned attacker leaves the ball and does not affect an opponent while an onside team-mate receives it. In the second, the positioned attacker directly challenges the defender for that ball. Similar starting positions need not imply the same offence analysis.

These examples explain why a position diagram is insufficient. They do not replace the official assessment of a real challenge or obstruction, which can depend on movement and the opponent’s opportunity to act.

A defender’s touch is not a universal reset

A frequent shortcut is to say that any defender contact cancels offside. The law makes finer distinctions involving deliberate play, deflections and deliberate saves. The mere fact that the ball touched an opponent does not settle the issue.

Review the sequence at normal speed as well as in slow motion. Look for the nature of the opponent’s action and the conditions in which the ball arrived. A limited reflex contact is not automatically equivalent to a controlled opportunity to play the ball.

A save is another important distinction. Do not assume that because a goalkeeper or defender intentionally stopped an attempt, every subsequent attacker can receive the rebound without an offside question.

Where the footage or official explanation is incomplete, state which distinction remains uncertain. Avoid inventing an official rationale or describing the contact as deliberate merely because that interpretation fits the preferred outcome.

Check how play restarted

Law 11 provides specific direct-receipt exceptions for a goal kick, a throw-in and a corner kick. That does not mean every later pass in the resulting attack is exempt. A new team-mate touch can create a new relevant assessment.

Record the restart and then follow the actual sequence. In an invented corner routine, receiving directly from the corner and receiving from a later team-mate pass are different events. The words “from a corner” in a short match report can hide that distinction.

Also distinguish an offence decision from the location where a restart is taken. A still of the subsequent free kick is not necessarily evidence of the attacker’s original position at the relevant team-mate touch.

If several potential offences occur in one sequence, avoid assuming that the last visible event caused the decision. Use the referee’s signal and the official account where available, rather than reverse-engineering a reason from the scoreboard.

Do not manufacture precision from a broadcast angle

Camera perspective can make a player appear closer to goal than another who is at a different distance from the lens. A hand-drawn horizontal screen line is not necessarily aligned with the pitch or a valid measurement of body-part positions.

A cropped image can omit the opponent who actually sets the reference line. It can also remove the ball, making an assessment based solely on a defender incomplete. Preserve a sufficiently wide frame and the preceding movement.

Where the competition uses video or semi-automated assistance, distinguish the technology’s positional information from the separate judgement about involvement. Do not infer which process was used from the presence of a television graphic alone.

A careful article can explain the relevant principles without declaring a millimetre-level result from inadequate material. “The available angle does not establish this” is a useful finding, not a failure to take a side.

Keep match analysis and betting settlement separate

An attack ruled offside can help explain why a promising move did not become a valid scoring event. It does not mean the team was guaranteed to score if the whistle had stayed down. Preserve what actually happened and label any alternative scenario as hypothetical.

The treatment of disallowed attempts in a data feed depends on the provider’s definitions and corrections. Check coverage before treating a missing shot as an error or adding an unofficial xG value to a published total.

The expected-goals review guide explains the limits of shot-based descriptions. The non-penalty adjustment guide demonstrates the same need to keep event definitions consistent.

For betting records, retain the operator’s actual settlement and the applicable market terms. A personal disagreement with an offside decision does not justify replacing the settled match outcome in a performance table.

Write a sequence rather than a verdict from one frame

A useful review records the relevant team-mate contact, the player’s position relative to the ball and opponents, the action that created involvement, any intervening opponent play and the official outcome. Note which elements are observed and which remain unavailable.

That structure gives a reader a way to inspect the reasoning. It also prevents a correct statement about position from being stretched into an unsupported conclusion about an offence, a goal or a future match.

Test the explanation against a contrasting sequence

Before accepting a review, change one condition in an explicitly hypothetical scenario. Suppose the runner is ahead of the second-last opponent but behind the ball at the relevant contact. An explanation based only on the opponent’s line has omitted a material part of the position test.

Next consider footage that shows a positioned attacker but not the eventual reception or challenge. The available image may support a position observation while leaving involvement unestablished. Describe those two evidential conclusions separately instead of extending one beyond what is visible.

Finally, compare a direct throw-in receipt with an attack that begins with a throw-in but includes a later team-mate pass. Describing both simply as throw-in situations conceals an event that could matter. Write the actual sequence rather than relying on its opening label.

These counterexamples test the completeness of an explanation. They are not a method for overturning a referee from a television angle. Keep the sporting decision, the supporting footage and any missing evidence in separate parts of the account.

For adults aged 18 and over. Situations described here are illustrative. Rules should be checked against the edition applicable to the competition; this article does not claim to adjudicate a particular fixture.

독자 토론

댓글 0

아직 댓글이 없습니다.

댓글 남기기

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *